Massaman Curry – The Untold Story (แกงมัสมั่น – แกงมาชะแมน – แกงหมัดสมั่น)

Click to listen to the Thai name pronunciation Listen to the Thai name pronunciation
By: Hanuman, Thaan Khun and Chef Thapakorn Lertviriyavit (Gorn)

This page is also available in: Thai

Chicken Massaman Curry RecipeConsidered by some to be the most famous, and the most delicious, dish in Thai cooking, the story of Massaman curry is interwoven with trade, politics and religion in 17th-century Siam. The story is filled with mighty kings, legendary explorers and unsolved mysteries, adding an air of magic and power to this already-heavenly perfumed dish, and thickening the plot of this full bodied, coconut-based curry’s birth.

Massaman is usually made with chicken, beef, lamb, mutton or goat. Sometimes the meat is fried in butter or fat, prior to simmering it in sweet spices and coconut milk until the meat softens and the curry thickens, a process called khao gathi (เข้ากะทิ).

In the Arabian culinary tradition, almonds (ลูกมะด่ำ, อัลมอนด์), peanuts or sultana raisins (ลูกกิจเสม็ด) are included to add joy and richness; and the dish is seasoned to a sour-leading sweet, to follow the taste with a pleasant, throat-cooling sensation.

The Thais adapted this curry using Thai ingredients such as fermented shrimp paste (kapi), lemongrass, tamarind and bitter orange juice, and making it spicier. Sometimes potatoes were added, and even pineapple – Massaman curry was considered a dish reserved for special occasions and religious ceremonies.

Massaman curry, or ‘the curry of the Muslim’, was popular among Siam’s residents of Muslim descent for many centuries. The Thai word moot salim, or ‘Muslim’ (มุสลิม), is derived from the Persian/ Arabic word moot limaan (มุสลิมาน).

While its origins are obscure, we will suggest that two scenarios are possible:

  1. Massaman was introduced to Siam directly via Muslim Persian traders in the 17th century.
  2. Massaman was created in Siam’s Muslim communities, using Muslim culinary codes and Siamese ingredients, during the Ayutthaya period or as late as the Thonburi era (18th century).

Gezicht_op_Judea,_de_hoofdstad_van_Siam_Rijksmuseum_SK-A-4477Persian influence during the Ayutthaya period
The period of Persian influence appears to have begun in early 17th-century Ayutthaya, reaching a peak during the reign of King Phra Narai (1656-1688). After a series of coups, rebellions and power struggles provoked by ambitious princes, King Phra Narai came to power with the active assistance of the Iranians and the Japanese, who stormed the royal palace, allowing Prince Narai to usurp the throne from his uncle, Somdet Chaofa Chai.

During King Phra Narai’s reign, foreign communities in Siam flourished due to religious and political factors. As well, the Siamese court actively encouraged increased foreign trade and settlement in Siam in an effort to expand trade and generate more revenue for the Royal Treasury.

Most of the Thai written records from that period were burned in the flames that swept and consumed the capital during its 1767 fall to the Burmese. Thus foreign records of the time – as biased as they may be – are of great value in the reconstruction of Thai history.

The Iranian Ibn Muhammad Ibraham (Muhammad Rabi), a diplomat dispatched to Siam in 1685 by the Safavid ruler, Shah Sulaiman, calls Narai “The king of white elephants and the throne of solid gold”; he describes in his chronicles, “The Ship of Sulaiman”, the king’s strong affiliation with Persian culture:

“When King Narai was still a boy he used to visit the Iranians regularly, and he took great pleasure in their social manners and their foods and drink. In that way he became quite familiar with the Persian style of life.”

Sunni Muslims, from countries west of Siam or of Indo-Malay origin. settled outside the city walls near the river where the merchant ships were moored, practicing the import and export of goods from Siam.

Shiite Persian Muslims were granted residence within the city walls side-by-side with the Chinese and the Siamese elite. They were mainly merchants who bought and sold luxury goods such as Persian carpets, rose water, opulent fabrics, jewelry and gold ornaments; their clientele were, naturally, members of the aristocracy of that era. These connections, and subsequent interaction between the Persian Muslims and the Siamese, also most likely facilitated culinary exchange.

Some descendants of Persians from the Ayutthaya period eventually converted to Buddhism, and continue to maintain a presence in Thai public life to the present day; a prominent example is the Bunnag family, whose ancestor, Sheikh Ahmad Qomi, is said to have come from the Safavid dynasty, and who arrived in Ayutthaya from Persia in 1602. He had risen to the position of Jao Krom Ta Kwa (เจ้ากรมท่าขวา), literally ‘Lord of the Right Pier’, in charge of all seaborn trade traffic coming from the West to Ayutthaya. He also rose to the rank of Chularachamontri, the royal overseer of Muslims in Siam.

Muslim communities in Thonburi
After the fall of Ayutthaya in 1767, the Muslim communities fled to Bangkok. Led by Sheikh Ahmad Qomi, they settled in communities around the Klong Bang Luang canal (also known as Bangkok Yai Canal) (คลองบางหลวง). Many were rafters, selling various goods; they were described as Khaaek Phae, or Thai Muslims who lived on rafts along the canal.

28993-01

Gulf of Siam
Carte du Cours du Menam Depuis Siam, Jusqu´a la Mer.
Paris, N. Bellin 1760

The Kudi Khao, or Bang Luang, community is one of the oldest Thai-Muslim communities in Bangkok.  This Islamic influence is reflected in the mosques (Kud กุฎี) in the area – Kudi Khao Mosque (กุฎีขาว), built in the 18th century, and Ton Son Mosque – and through delicacies that permeate the air with tempting aromas, including Massaman curry (แกงมัสมั่น), guruma curry (แกงกูรุม่า), roti (ลุดตี่ โรตี), room (หรุ่ม) and khanom muscat (มัสกอด).

These dishes made their way into the royal Thai cuisine as early as the beginning of the Ratanakosin era; King Phra Phutthayotfa Chulalok (Rama I) was from the vicinity of Klong Luang canal, and it is likely that he was on good terms with the Muslim community and thus familiar with its cooking.

It was in his reign that Kudi Khao Mosque (กุฎีขาว) was built; the structure is similar to that of a Buddhist temple, with green terracotta roof tiles – green being a symbolic color in Islam. Moreover, one of the King’s consorts was a member of the Muslim community: Jao Jom hohng was the daughter of a Thai Muslim community leader, Chularachamontree (Gorn Keaw) (เจ้าจอมหงส์ ธิดาพระยาจุฬาราชมนตรี, ก้อนแก้ว).

The leaders of these Thai Muslim communities had court responsibilities, such as looking after the food offered to monks and visitors during the 1809 celebration of the Temple of the Emerald Buddha (Wat Phra Kaew).

Muslim cuisine, therefore, was quite familiar to the Siamese court, and we can find mention of Muslim dishes in the era’s literature and poetry, the records and chronicles, and even in the writings of King Rama II.

In the early 1800s, King Rama II wrote the following passage in the boat poem, “Gaap Heh Chohm Khreuuang Khaao Waan (กาพย์เห่ชมเครื่องคาว – หวาน)”, sung during the procession of the royal barge:

“Matsaman curry is like a lover, as peppery and fragrant as the cumin seed. Its exciting allure would arouse any man. I am urged to seek its source” (translation: Phanu 2010).

The dishes referenced in King Rama II’s poetry were attributed to Queen Sri Suriyendra (Princess Bunrod), whose family came to settle in the waterways of Klong Bang Luang after they fled Ayutthaya. It was during her childhood in Klong Bang Luang that she developed her cooking skills, adopting foreign-influenced dishes from the area’s ethnically diverse settlers.

Summary:
We have examined the relationship that developed over two centuries between the Siamese and Persian-Arab communities prior to the first mention of Massaman curry in the poetry written by King Rama II; we have also revealed the impact of the influential Muslim communities of Bang Luang during the Thonburi and early Ratanakosin periods; and the position  that enabled the sharing of their culinary codes with the aristocratic food culture. These are all factors that contributed to the culinary exchange between the Siamese and the Muslims, a fertile ground from which Massaman was born – a Muslim curry that incorporates Thai ingredients and has become a truly Thai dish.

What follows is a detailed examination of the two first-known recipes for Massaman curry ever written in Thai. Beef Massaman, by Maawm Sohm Jeen (1890), and chicken Massaman by Lady Plean Passakornrawong (1889). It is important to mention that both ladies were married to descendants of the aforementioned Sheikh Ahmad Qomi of Bunnag lineage.

Beef Massaman curry

(gaaeng massaman neuua, แกงมัสมั่นเนื้อ, แกงมาชะแมนเนื้อโค) – as written by Maawm Sohm Jeen 1890 (2433 BE, 109RE) – spelled maa cha maaen (มาชะแมน)

Chicken Massaman Curry Recipe

Beef Massaman curry
แกงมาชะแมนเนื้อโค

This is the recipe for beef Massaman that appeared in the 1890 (2433 BE, 109RE) book “Tam Raa Gap Khao (ตำรากับเข้า)”. Published by the Wacharin printing company (โรงพิมพ์วัชรินทร์) and written by Maawm Sohm Jeen, this is considered to be the first complete cookbook ever published in the Thai language.

Maawm Sohm Jeen provide two recipes for Massaman, which she spells maa cha maaen (มาชะแมน): the recipes are the same, differing only in the meat used. The first is made of beef, lamb, domestic (imported) or wild rabbit, or fish (perch, ปลาหมอ). In the second recipe, she uses goat for the Massaman.

Maawm Sohm Jeen begins by cutting the meat (600 gr) into large pieces and frying it either in ghee or pork fat. For goat meat, she specifically directs the reader to use ghee for the frying process, as pork fat will spoil the goat Massaman curry taste. Once the meat is cooked and has a golden color, it is set aside.

Chicken Massaman Curry Recipe

A curry paste is then made from equal quantities (3.75 gr each) of charred dry long chilies, roasted cumin seeds, roasted coriander seeds, roasted lemongrass and roasted white peppercorns, to which 15 small charred shallots and the entire amount of salt needed for the dish are added. Each curry ingredient is roasted before it is pounded smooth.

The curry paste is dissolved in coconut cream, and allowed to come to a boil until the oil has separated and is floating on the top; then the pre-fried meat is added back into the curry, and immersed until covered with coconut milk. Maawm Sohm Jeen then adds sliced ginger (15 gr), 15 pcs of cloves, and cinnamon (3.75 gr), letting all come to a boil again before she adds bitter orange juice, which Maawm Sohm Jeen says is preferable to  tamarind. The lid is closed, and the meat is simmered until tender. Finally, she adds 5-6 bay leaves and 20 small charred roasted shallots, and seasons the curry with 15 gr palm sugar.

Chicken Massaman Curry Recipe

Maawm Sohm Jeen explains that, according to the Khaaek tradition, a good Massaman should have a sour-leading sweet to follow taste with a pleasant cooling throat sensation. She also mentions that one can add almonds (อามันด้ม) or roasted peanuts if desired.

This version of Massaman curry does not uses potatoes or onions, and the flavor it presents is not as sweet or as complex as modern day Massaman.

The first-ever recorded recipe for Massaman curry:
Chicken Massaman curry with bitter orange juice

(gaaeng massaman sai naam sohm saa, แกงมัสมั่นใส่น้ำส้มซ่า, แกงหมัดสมั่นกับน้ำซ่มซ่า) – as written by Lady Plean Passakornrawong in 1889 (2432 BE, 108RE) – spelled Matsaman (หมัดสมั่น)

Chicken Massaman Curry Recipe

Chicken Massaman curry with bitter orange juice
แกงหมัดสมั่นกับน้ำซ่มซ่า

Bpradtithin Bat Laae Joht Maai Haeht (ประติทินบัตร แล จดหมายเหตุ) was a monthly journal published just five times between 1889 and 1890. In this publication, Lady Plean Passakornrawong, who in 1908 will write the epic cookbook “Maae Khruaa Huaa Bpaa” (แม่ครัวหัวป่าก์), published a food column in which she shared recipes.

Massaman is the first recipe that Lady Plean (gaaeng matsaman sai naam sohm saa, แกงหมัดสมั่นกับน้ำซ่มซ่า) published: it is thus the earliest known recipe for Massaman curry written in the Thai language.

The curry paste in Lady Plean’s version is more complex than Maawm Sohm Jeen’s, and contains dry chilies, mace, nutmeg, Thai cardamom, coriander seeds, cumin seeds, white peppercorns, lemongrass, coriander root, shallots, garlic, salt, and fermented shrimp paste (kapi) – each one of the ingredients is roasted, and then pounded into a fine paste.

The chicken is simmered in coconut milk; the curry paste, separately, is fried until fragrant in generous amounts of pork fat, and then mixed into the simmering chicken. Shallots and sultana raisins (called gitsamet, กิจเสม็ด) are added, and the curry is seasoned with palm sugar, fish sauce and tamarind paste; just before serving, a generous amount of bitter orange juice is added.

Here we would like to thank Dr Kusuma Raksamanee from P.E.N. International Thailand-Centre, who kindly explained to us that the word “gitsamet (กิจเสม็ด)”, as it appears in the recipe, is derived from the Hindi word “kishmish (किशमिश)”, meaning “raisins”.

Again, the curry should be thick and gravy-like, with a leading sour taste that leaves as a distant echo both the sweetness and saltiness.

You could see by now that old-style Massaman curry has a sour-sweet-cold flavor, and is cooked traditionally without potatoes or yams. In the early days, it would be served with a spice-infused rice dish, khaao boo ree (ข้าวบุหรี่), that is the Thai version of yet another Persian dish – Biryani rice (ข้าวบริญานี) – or the curry would be served together with roti (โรตี หรือลุดตี่ แป้งกลอก), the Thai version of Indian bread.

Possible modifications, and a “please do not” request

  1. Please resist the urge to add herbs; this is Massaman curry, and your herbs should remain in the herb planter box.
  2. If you choose to follow the recipe described below, in which we closely followed the original, you can deep fry the chicken first, and also deep fry the onions and potatoes if you choose to use them in the curry.
  3. While Lady Plean uses only raisins, we highly recommend the addition of peanuts as well, for an extra earthy-nutty flavor.
Chicken Massaman Curry Recipe
 
Prep time
Cook time
Ready In
 
This is the first-ever recorded recipe for Massaman curry - published in 1889 in Bpradtithin Bat Laae Joht Maai Haeht (ประติทินบัตร แล จดหมายเหตุ) by Lady Plean Passakornrawong.
By:
Recipe type: Curry
Cuisine: Thai
Serves: 6

Ingredients

 
  • 6 pcs chicken thighs or drumsticks
  • 3 cups coconut cream
  • 4 cups coconut milk
  • 1 cup (190 gr) massaman curry paste
  • 2 1/2 tablespoons pork fat (or ghee)
  • 20 small shallots (about 200 gr)
  • 1 cup sultana raisins
  • 1 cup unsalted peanuts (optional, not in the original recipe)
  • 2 1/2 tablespoons fish sauce
  • 2 tablespoons palm sugar
  • 2 tablespoons tamarind paste
  • 3/4 cup bitter orange juice (sohm sa)
massaman curry paste
  • 30 dry long red chilies, deseeded and char roasted
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 2 1/2 tablespoons lemongrass, finely sliced and roasted
  • 2 1/2 tablespoons coriander root, sliced and roasted
  • 1/2 cup shallots, char roasted and peeled
  • 2 1/2 tablespoons Thai garlic, peeled and roasted
  • 2 teaspoons coriander seeds, roasted
  • 2 teaspoons cumin seeds, roasted
  • 2 teaspoons white peppercorns, roasted
  • 1 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  • 2 tablespoons mace, roasted
  • 3 pcs Thai cardamom, roasted
  • 1 tablespoon fermented shrimp paste (kapi), grilled
  • 2 sticks of cinnamon (10 gr) (optional, not in the original recipe)
Method
  1. An overview image of the curry paste ingredients; each has been separately roasted.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  2. Charred roasted dry long chilies.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  3. Pound all the ingredients into a smooth paste, and set aside.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  4. Simmer the chicken in coconut milk until it is cooked.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  5. Heat the pork fat over medium heat, and fry the curry paste until fragrant.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  6. Gradually add cooking liquids from the chicken, and continue frying until it incorporates into the curry.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  7. Keep stirring until a beautiful red oil floats on top.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  8. Continue this until all the liquids are mixed together, then add the cooked chicken.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  9. Add shallots.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  10. Add sultana raisins.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  11. Cook until the shallots are soft, and the curry thickens to the desired consistency.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  12. Add fish sauce.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  13. Add palm sugar.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  14. Add tamarind paste.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  15. Squeeze bitter orange juice.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น
  16. Serve.
    Massaman Curry - แกงมัสมั่น